Wisconsin judge convicted of obstruction for aiding immigrant

A Wisconsin judge has been convicted of obstruction after attempting to help an undocumented immigrant evade ICE officers.

Wisconsin judge convicted of obstruction for aiding immigrant

December 19, 2025

Benjamin Hart

Judge Hannah Dugan Found Guilty

A federal jury found a Wisconsin judge guilty on Thursday night of felony obstruction after she attempted to assist an undocumented immigrant in evading U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers at her courthouse earlier this year.

The jury acquitted Judge Hannah Dugan of a misdemeanor charge related to concealment aimed at preventing arrest.

Dugan’s defense team has indicated plans to appeal the verdict, marking her as a notable figure in the Trump administration’s efforts against resistance to ICE operations.

The incident occurred on April 18 when an illegal immigrant, Eduardo Flores-Ruiz, was scheduled to appear before Dugan on battery charges. Upon realizing that ICE officers were present to arrest him following her proceedings, she instructed them to speak with the chief judge instead.

Dugan then abruptly ended the court session and led Flores-Ruiz out through a non-public exit.

A fellow judge testified that Dugan admitted to trying to assist Flores-Ruiz. Although he managed to leave the courthouse, he was subsequently apprehended by members of the arrest team, which included FBI and Customs and Border Protection agents.

Dugan contended that since the immigration arrest was civil in nature, it did not constitute an obstructive proceeding for a sitting judge. Her legal team argued that federal agents had no right to execute civil warrants within the courthouse on that day.

The request for case dismissal was denied by U.S. District Judge Lynn Adelman.

Following the verdict, Dugan’s legal representatives outlined their strategy for appeal. They expressed disappointment but noted that the prosecution’s failure to secure convictions on both counts provided an opportunity to clear her name.

The defense team stated: “We have planned for this potential outcome and our defense of Judge Dugan is just beginning.” They also appealed for donations to support her legal expenses.

The incident drew political attention, with Democrats rallying in support of Dugan during the event. Representative Jamie Raskin from Maryland described the charges as “chilling” and part of an authoritarian campaign against judges who resist political pressure from Trump.

Attorney General Pam Bondi countered: She argued that this case was not appropriate for political posturing, emphasizing that Flores-Ruiz had previously been deported in 2013 and had no right to return. She also highlighted serious allegations against him related to violent crimes leading up to his deportation last month after pleading guilty to illegal reentry.

Edited by:

Benjamin Hart

Photo of author
I focus on national security, defense policy, and military affairs, prioritizing accuracy and sober analysis. My work aims to clarify what matters beneath headlines and rhetoric.

Leave a Comment