China’s Declaration of a Nature Reserve
China’s recent announcement of a nature reserve on a contested shoal in the South China Sea has been deemed illegal and an example of Beijing’s legal warfare, according to a report from the U.S. Indo-Pacific Command.
In September, Beijing unilaterally established a national nature reserve covering 13.5 square miles at Scarborough Reef, located approximately 120 miles west of the Philippine island of Luzon. This reef is claimed by China, the Philippines, and Taiwan.
The report from the Hawaii-based military command indicated that Chinese coast guard vessels began enforcing this reserve on October 13, instructing Philippine vessels to remain outside what is now referred to as an “environmental reserve.”
The command’s staff judge advocate office stated, “China’s nature reserve represents another example of legal warfare — i.e., China’s misuse and weaponization of legal mechanisms to create a veneer of legitimacy to justify its malign actions.”
The report highlights China’s ongoing pattern of aggressive behavior in the South China Sea, which includes harassment of Philippine vessels within their exclusive economic zone and imposing unfounded fishing bans over waters where it lacks legal entitlement under international law.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth recently condemned China’s declaration regarding Scarborough Reef. He remarked, “We recently saw Beijing’s unjustifiable claim of Scarborough Reef as a so-called nature reserve,” emphasizing that one cannot establish military platforms within such reserves.
This statement raises concerns that China may intend to deploy military assets near or on the newly declared reserve area.
During discussions with defense ministers from ASEAN nations in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, Hegseth described China’s actions as attempts to coerce new territorial claims at the expense of neighboring countries while undermining their sovereignty.
The Indo-Pacom report asserts that Chinese activities at Scarborough Reef threaten regional stability and are part of a broader strategy aimed at advancing illegal maritime claims while eroding international norms.
The United States firmly rejects these actions as destabilizing and coercive tactics aimed at undermining its allies’ interests across the Indo-Pacific region.


