Shift in U.S. Foreign Policy
SEOUL, South Korea – The recent pivot of the Trump administration from Europe and Asia towards a greater emphasis on the Western Hemisphere has left American allies worldwide reevaluating their relationships with the United States.
This new approach, referred to by critics as the “Donroe Doctrine,” asserts U.S. influence over the Americas, stretching from Venezuela to Greenland. Critics warn that this could create opportunities for China and Russia to expand their own agendas, with Moscow potentially justifying its ambitions in Eastern Europe and Beijing seeking to assert its power in the Indo-Pacific.
Moon Chung-in, a Seoul-based academic and geostrategist, expressed concerns about diminishing U.S. presence in East Asia if America continues down this path. He emphasized the need for alternative strategies.
Despite his advisory role to various leaders in Seoul regarding North Korea relations, Moon’s critiques resonate across political lines in both Korea and the U.S., highlighting widespread apprehension about Trump’s global strategy.
Many conservatives in the U.S. are alarmed by President Trump’s apparent disregard for NATO commitments and his favorable stance towards Russia.
Related: U.S.-Japan defense cooperation intensifies with new missile systems
Moon noted that Trump’s approach appears transactional and situational rather than grounded in established alliances or historical contexts.
The unilateral tariffs imposed by Trump on exports from allied nations have further strained relationships, alongside demands for significant investments into U.S. reindustrialization efforts.
The recent focus on the Western Hemisphere—highlighted by actions against Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro and interest in Greenland—has left many allies stunned. European nations worry that a U.S. takeover of Greenland could destabilize NATO, while Asian countries fear being sidelined.
Moon suggested there may be growing divisions between Trump’s administration and military leaders regarding strategic priorities in the Indo-Pacific region. Key figures like Undersecretary of Defense Elbridge Colby advocate for prioritizing China as a central concern.
If America reduces its involvement in Asia, Moon proposes two potential paths for regional democracies: one that excludes China or another that seeks cooperation with it through models similar to the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE).
No single alliance currently unites Asian nations; instead, security is typically managed through bilateral treaties with countries like Australia, the Philippines, South Korea, and Japan. Some have proposed an “Asian NATO,” but this idea has not gained traction.
Taiwan remains a critical security issue; however, adherence to the “One China Policy” complicates any potential alliances involving Taipei.
An OSCE-like organization could foster confidence-building measures such as personnel exchanges and joint drills while promoting economic integration as a buffer against conflict.


