Experts weigh in on potential consequences
Military law professionals suggest that the administration of President Trump is unlikely to pursue criminal charges against six Democratic lawmakers who recently urged service members in an online video to disregard illegal orders from the commander in chief.
While the experts noted that Senator Mark Kelly, a Democrat from Arizona, could face penalties, they believe it is improbable.
This discussion follows President Trump and Secretary of War Pete Hegseth labeling the group as the “Seditious Six,” with Trump suggesting on social media that they are “traitors to our country” who should be arrested and tried.
Eugene Fidell, a military justice professor at Yale Law School, criticized the president’s remarks as “harassment with real danger attached.” He described the situation as a “silly mock investigation by the Pentagon.”
Fidell raised questions about why there is court-martial jurisdiction over retirees, indicating potential for abuse within the system. Legal scholars assert that five of the six lawmakers are protected by the First Amendment; however, since Kelly is a former military member, he falls under military court jurisdiction.
Retired Air Force Major General Charles J. Dunlap Jr. pointed out that while retired officers retain their commissions and are subject to military law, it is rare for retired personnel to be recalled under such circumstances. He emphasized that speech protected under civilian law could be criminalized under military law.
Brenner M. Fissell, a professor specializing in military and national security law at Villanova University, believes any case against Kelly would likely be dismissed due to significant legal hurdles. He noted that Kelly’s statement did not encourage disobedience but rather advised against following unlawful orders.
The Pentagon has initiated an investigation into Kelly’s actions after he was accused of undermining loyalty and discipline within the armed forces. Kelly has denied any wrongdoing and characterized the investigation as an attempt by “bullies” to intimidate him and other Congress members from fulfilling their duties.
The remaining lawmakers involved are not subject to military jurisdiction and can rely on First Amendment protections if faced with allegations. The video they released encouraged service members not to follow unlawful orders but did not specify any illegal directives from Trump.


