Court Delays Contempt Hearing for Trump Officials

A federal appeals court has paused upcoming contempt hearings involving Trump officials amid concerns over separation of powers.

Court Delays Contempt Hearing for Trump Officials

December 13, 2025

Jason Miller

Federal Appeals Court Issues Stay

A federal appeals court has temporarily halted Judge James Boasberg’s plans to conduct hearings next week regarding the potential criminal contempt of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem. The judges indicated they require additional time to assess the situation.

The three-judge panel voted 2-1 to issue a stay on the hearings, originally scheduled for Monday and Tuesday. They stated that this pause will remain in effect until they can thoroughly evaluate the issues at hand.

This decision represents a temporary victory for the Justice Department, which had urgently requested the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia to intervene and halt Judge Boasberg’s proceedings.

Justice Department attorneys argued that Judge Boasberg’s actions threaten the separation of powers among government branches. The hearings were called to investigate events from March 15, when Secretary Noem continued deportation flights to El Salvador despite the judge’s orders.

Tiberius Davis, another DOJ attorney, emphasized that these proceedings also infringe upon attorney-client privilege. He urged the appeals court to act swiftly to prevent an unnecessary constitutional conflict between the Executive and Judicial branches.

Judge Boasberg intended to hear from a former Justice Department lawyer who became a whistleblower, as well as a current DOJ lawyer during these hearings.

The focus is on flights carrying Venezuelan migrants allegedly linked to Tren de Aragua and some Salvadorans deported on March 15 under the Alien Enemies Act, which bypasses standard immigration procedures.

Among those deported was Kilmar Abrego Garcia. On that day, Judge Boasberg had ordered that planes be grounded; however, two were already airborne when his order was issued. The third flight took off after his directive but was claimed by the Justice Department to be compliant with normal immigration law.

The Supreme Court later determined that Judge Boasberg lacked jurisdiction over these flights but acknowledged his concerns regarding potential defiance of his orders.

This belief is bolstered by claims from Erez Reuveni, a recently dismissed DOJ lawyer, who alleged he participated in discussions where senior officials planned to disregard any judicial attempts to ground these flights. Mr. Reuveni was set to testify on Monday; however, this is now postponed.

Judge Boasberg also sought testimony from Drew Ensign, who represented Secretary Noem during the events of March 15. Mr. Ensign has submitted a declaration asserting his involvement was limited to providing legal advice protected by attorney-client privilege.

Noem’s Defense Against Testifying, The Government’s Objections.

Edited by:

Jason Miller

Photo of author
I have spent decades covering U.S. politics, federal institutions, and power dynamics in Washington. I believe in context, accountability, and reporting that respects the intelligence of the reader.

Leave a Comment